I posted this story some time ago on FFN. For whatever reason, after reading several stories...
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
User | Total |
---|---|
killgore444 | 2 |
Why wouldn't you be?Didn't know we were allowed to link to outside fanfiction sites.
A-New-Tournament
A pyrrhic victory
Pensieve
their memories
disapparate
ceased to be
QQ competes by being not completely terrible. So far it's not a bad strategy.For some reason, I thought that talking about other sites was ok, but not posting links. Competition and all that jazz. Several of the furom sites I've been on have a zero tolerance for outside links. Anti-spam mostly.
It also is the only one of the "big three" forums I have found (SB, SV, and QQ) that allows mature content, and even most of the minor forums I have stumbled upon have not allowed it. So that keeps them competitive as well.QQ competes by being not completely terrible. So far it's not a bad strategy.
This will be something of a change then. I do still like FFN a little more for the way they organize their site, it makes finding a story somewhat easier.QQ competes by being not completely terrible. So far it's not a bad strategy.
I already planned on moving most of that to other posts. I'm new enough on this site to not know how to do thread-marks however.Reading ahead, I have two things I want to mention about this story. One, I hope you will pull out all the random stuff at the beginning and ending of the chapters. You have a lot explanations about why you are doing this or that thing, which should go in Informational Threadmarks if it gets posted at all, as well as a few responses to reviews that shouldn't be carried over. Two, you should not have the sections in Italics be italics. It just makes it harder to read.
It's nice and all, but that's actually something that doesn't bother me so much. The owners have the right to say no fanfiction and go after anyone who posts it. So when they say follow these rules, I've no trouble obliging. And a LOT of authors have said no smut stories. FFN has a list of authors who've said no fanfiction in general, largely over this, and others have threatened it. It's why a lot of sites ban mature content (although some of them have funny standards and lackadaisical enforcement).It also is the only one of the "big three" forums I have found (SB, SV, and QQ) that allows mature content, and even most of the minor forums I have stumbled upon have not allowed it. So that keeps them competitive as well.
Per pottermore it was Saul Croaker, and his specialty was time magic, but you have stated that you do not actually take pottermore as canon for this story so up to you if you actually use that.BTW, any one know what Croaker's [from the Dept of Mystery] first name was?
There's another distinction that most people in fanfiction miss. It was both Ron, and Harry who talked shit about Draco. Not just Ron himself talking shit. Hell, when Ron, Harry, and Draco first met as a group, Ron didn't say shit about Draco, and it was Harry hanging shit on him.Ron and Harry talked shit about Draco and vice verso constantly. It didn't make any of it true.
That's a distinction most people in fanfiction miss. Just because someone says something, doesn't make it accurate.
And lets not forget, that until 6th year (when people were being killed), the only person to actually attack Draco outside of self defense, was Hermione.There's another distinction that most people in fanfiction miss. It was both Ron, and Harry who talked shit about Draco. Not just Ron himself talking shit. Hell, when Ron, Harry, and Draco first met as a group, Ron didn't say shit about Draco, and it was Harry hanging shit on him.
You have significant issues with the punctuation of dialogue. Both of these, for instance, use a rather... awkward... form. As is, the segment prior to the dialogue tag is left grammatically hanging, with the tag applied solely to the following quote. The chapter basically starts with these, so they're just convenient examples... but hardly the worst."Of course he is, Ron's not capable of not being a git." Ginny responded, "I don't understand why you ever hung out with him anyway."
The action of turning is an action beat, not a dialogue tag. As such, it's a separate sentence.
None of these are complete sentences. Grammatically, they're sentence fragments.Unable to quite grasp why he lost his temper like that, but knowing it was needed. Nor did he know what he was doing here, only that this too was necessary to his goals. Back and forth, thinking about what his wish had been.
... like that.Harry grinned to himself at the idea of some ancient Dark Lord killing all of his followers who happened to see someone survive the curse. But then again, whoever figured it out would be dead to.
I'm mostly done with chapter 6 now. I've had several issues that have made writing something less then important, but I'm getting back into it now. Part of the reason I am reposting this here is that I've seen some of the commentary on stories here, and it's a lot more polite than on FFN, or God forbid, SB.I remember this from FF.net. Hopefully we'll get to see more of it -- it kinda ends on a cliffhanger at the moment.
Thank you. It's been well over thirty years since I've learned this in school, and I wasn't very good with it then either. I'm well aware that I'll never be a professional writer.You have significant issues with the punctuation of dialogue. Both of these, for instance, use a rather... awkward... form. As is, the segment prior to the dialogue tag is left grammatically hanging, with the tag applied solely to the following quote. The chapter basically starts with these, so they're just convenient examples... but hardly the worst.
Even having read the link before replying, I'm having trouble with this one. The same with through and thru.
I AM trying. And I do apologize over it, but it is something that will likely always be an issue with me. As for a proofreader, I've done that. All I got back was "corrections" on canon and story direction rather than grammar and spelling. The only people I know that don't do that have far less time then me to write.The cumulative effect is an appreciable irritant as I read the story. It's not nearly as bad as some stories I've seen, but you really need a competent proofreader.
This is what proofreaders are for.While I would never take the time to read a story that was this bad, I, in general, can. This unfortunately means I have a problem making sure I get everything right myself.
"Thru" is shorthand. Unless you're using a compound that specifically uses that spelling (e.g. "drive-thru") or quoting something that uses it (e.g. shorthand notes), it has no place in a story like this.Even having read the link before replying, I'm having trouble with this one. The same with through and thru.
I don't have the time or spoons to manage, but you should be able to find someone... hopefully, anyway.Edit: Maybe I'll use people here as a proofreader for chapters after 5.
The correct way of quoting multiple paragraphs of dialogue from the same speaker is to put a quotation mark at the start of each paragraph, and one at the end of the final paragraph.Also, I do not know if this is the correct rule, but something I've seen a lot lately is several paragraphs under a single pair of quotation marks. Since this allows for an easier time figuring out who's actually speaking while still cutting down run on paragraphs, I'm using it. So if you get to the end of a paragraph and there's no quotation mark, and dialogue starts the next paragraph, it's the same speaker.
Thank you.
He's already started. The £56,000 in books he purchased in Diagon Alley, they included several on the mind arts. It won't come up until chapter 7 or 8 (depending on how long chapter 7 runs), but yes, he is studying it.I hope MC at least starts on occlumency before his potion wears off.
This is already written into chapter 6, just not in the way you're thinking.Also hope he learns/studies methods of self-empowerment. Like, Alchemy, Rituals, Elixirs...
yea, but he also got ALL those books from the RoR, which it said were ALL the books that had EVER been in hogwarts. So that should include rituals and such. I mean, They taught classes on it in the past.Thank you.
He's already started. The £56,000 in books he purchased in Diagon Alley, they included several on the mind arts. It won't come up until chapter 7 or 8 (depending on how long chapter 7 runs), but yes, he is studying it.
This is already written into chapter 6, just not in the way you're thinking.
The main issue for stuff like this is, he has to THINK of it to start asking the How-To book about it. So unless it comes up in a book he bought in one of the alleys, he's not likely to think of it. Bear in mind, he doesn't even know (as of chapter 5 anyway) that basilisk blood can enhance goblin steel. To him, it's just toxic, nothing else. Although the information is there for him to learn. As for phoenix tears, to him Faux is a friend, not a source of ritual components. Faux would likely turn on Harry if did start thinking that way.
And everything he purchased in Madam Walpole's, except the animorphamagus book, is rather dark in nature. The horcrux ritual not even ranking in the top ten, so Harry's not likely to look at those as a good idea (but he's going to know how to counter them). And by association, any of the other books he got there. And Flourish and Blots doesn't carry books with rituals like that, being restricted (and dangerous) magic like the animorphamagus transformation.
Only the books students have semi-legitimate access to. There is a lot of dangerous crap in the Hogwarts library, but a lot of it outside the purview of students, even if they have access to the restricted section. Basically a staff only section that the RoR won't allow a student to access, a teacher would need to retrieve a book from it to lend to a student. Then there is the teachers private libraries that the RoR would only grant access to if it was the teacher in question asking.yea, but he also got ALL those books from the RoR, which it said were ALL the books that had EVER been in hogwarts. So that should include rituals and such. I mean, They taught classes on it in the past.
So, are the unspeakables wrong, and they just cannot "see" the divergent realities created by time travel... Or does it really work like that in this story? Since the Mirror lets you travel to divergent/alternate realities.