Lost novel.

[Ahtu]

So there was this novel on fanfiction, about a SI that got mangled up with the soul of Tom Dolder in the Diary, even as it was consuming Ginny to return to life. It was a gamer fic(mostly in the original "The Gamer" style), that showed the % he was at, and he chooses to go through with it. Because he doesn't want to risk being killed, because he's seen as the dark lord - While having basically no power to defend himself.

So at any rate, I can't find this novel anymore. I've tried to search my history, I've tried several search across various search engines, searched the site, searched here - Nothing. So now, at the end of my rope, I am gonna check the forums like this for someone that might know. Because ppl like we tend to(as a group), have read most everything. And usually a few others might know what you're talking about.

Help!

Oki wtf, nvm. This time I recheck the forums here, and lo and behold - It's among the first in the list. Under a new name it seems, but clearly the same story.

 

[SailorOfMyVessel]

Okay, but what is the story and can we have a link?

 

[Tsee]

Okay, but what is the story and can we have a link?

Click to shrink...

Spoiler: Large Image

Now, I don't feel that strongly, but Ahtu, if you're going to tell us a story is awesome and available, then put up a link.

 

[S.I.N]

Spoiler: Large Image

Now, I don't feel that strongly, but Ahtu, if you're going to tell us a story is awesome and available, then put up a link.

Click to shrink...

Yes link it or give us the name

 

[Ahtu]

https://forum.questionablequesting.com/threads/false-riddle-hp-tmr-si-gamer-multicross.9873/ Unfortunately it seems to have been shelved, or possibly originally written by another. Regardless, I can't find it having been continued since I last read it about a year or 2 earlier on Fanfiction I think.

PS. It seems just a little, tiny bit different than what I remember. But that may just be me mixing it up with some other novel.

 

[SailorOfMyVessel]

Well, it was okay and an interesting concept.

I've always had a weak spot for girl-who-lived stories, so cheers!

 

[Ahtu]

Well, it was okay and an interesting concept.

I've always had a weak spot for girl-who-lived stories, so cheers!

Click to shrink...

It's just a pity it just reaches into becoming that, and then just stops.

Do you happen to know any other good SI's into a young Tom Riddle?

It's basically hitting the jackpot. Stops the dark lord story in its tracks, and gives you the power of the most talented young wizard in recent history. Not to mention a pretty solid body(I mean he looks like an idyllic model for a male human body).

 

[SailorOfMyVessel]

It's just a pity it just reaches into becoming that, and then just stops.

Do you happen to know any other good SI's into a young Tom Riddle?

It's basically hitting the jackpot. Stops the dark lord story in its tracks, and gives you the power of the most talented young wizard in recent history. Not to mention a pretty solid body(I mean he looks like an idyllic model for a male human body).

Click to shrink...

I unfortunately don't. In fact, 'Tom Survives The Chamber Of Secrets' appears to be almost non existent in general(let alone SIs) , which is interesting.

Do so few people want to sacrifice Ginny? Hmmm

 

[S.I.N]

I unfortunately don't. In fact, 'Tom Survives The Chamber Of Secrets' appears to be almost non existent in general(let alone SIs) , which is interesting.

Do so few people want to sacrifice Ginny? Hmmm

Click to shrink...

Considering the mass amount of hatred for her I doubt that's it I think the idea just didn't catch on.

 

[Ahtu]

I unfortunately don't. In fact, 'Tom Survives The Chamber Of Secrets' appears to be almost non existent in general(let alone SIs) , which is interesting.

Do so few people want to sacrifice Ginny? Hmmm

Click to shrink...

To be clear, I don't need it to happen then and there, as interesting as that might be. I just want a SI into a teenage Tom Dolder. If that be through the diary or into him as a teenager back in the day - I don't really care. Both means situations to handle. Depending on what stage of his teens he is in, the difficulty of changing course could vary greatly. For example, if it's after creating his Horocrux, then you have that splintered soul scenario to deal with. Or his circle of "friends", or Dumbledore's scrutiny.

All in all, it could either be VERY easy. Or VERY hard. But no matter what, there's a lot you can change.

I love when SI's are put into pivotal and precarious spot. The story is filled with both obstacles, and opportunity. As well as foresight to deal with.

 

[Ahtu]

Considering the mass amount of hatred for her I doubt that's it I think the idea just didn't catch on.

Click to shrink...

I never quite grasped that... Sure I could see some reasons to be a bit annoyed/disappointed with her. But not much reason to outright hate her.

I can get those who hate Dumbledore(though not those who exaggerate his flaws out of proportions, or ascribe him new ones constantly). But Ginny did not do anything nearly so crazy.

She's a tad bratty, mistreated Luna a little bit out of either exasperation, or fear. Possibly both. And she took Hermione's rather shitty, and(for its purpose) vaguely disgusting advice(ofc, if Hermione merely meant to help her move on, that would have been something else). So all in all, not flawless. But nothing crazy.

 

[S.I.N]

I never quite grasped that... Sure I could see some reasons to be a bit annoyed/disappointed with her. But not much reason to outright hate her.

I can get those who hate Dumbledore(though not those who exaggerate his flaws out of proportions, or ascribe him new ones constantly). But Ginny did not do anything nearly so crazy.

She's a tad bratty, mistreated Luna a little bit out of either exasperation, or fear. Possibly both. And she took Hermione's rather shitty, and(for its purpose) vaguely disgusting advice(ofc, if Hermione merely meant to help her move on, that would have been something else). So all in all, not flawless. But nothing crazy.

Click to shrink...

It's the scene at the end half blood prince were she said Harry wouldn't be happy if he wasn't chasing Voldemort and that's why she likes him so much, it basically ruined her character for alot of fans.

 

[Ahtu]

It's the scene at the end half blood prince were she said Harry wouldn't be happy if he wasn't chasing Voldemort and that's why she likes him so much, it basically ruined her character for alot of fans.

Click to shrink...

So... They hate her for liking him, because his happiness relies on him trying to set things right?

I mean... Is it really that bad to like someone because they want to right wrongs?

I am not saying there isn't something slightly flawed with that, but cmon? Everyone is flawed, often deely so. This is hardly the worst. It's basically to love someone for their moral compass.

 

[S.I.N]

So... They hate her for liking him, because his happiness relies on him trying to set things right?

I mean... Is it really that bad to like someone because they want to right wrongs?

I am not saying there isn't something slightly flawed with that, but cmon? Everyone is flawed, often deely so. This is hardly the worst. It's basically to love someone for their moral compass.

Click to shrink...

It more along the line it comes across has her not understanding Harry because he doesn't want to fight Voldemort he has to fight. And sounds like she saying she likes him because he is hero. Which he doesn't want to be, Basically what said came across a lot differently than what she meant. And made her look horrible to the fandom. It doesn't help that in the next book she kissed Harry saying she doesn't want him to replace her if he comes across a veela Also sounded wrong to the fandom knowing Harry is going into the shit, basically she has the bad luck of everything she said being misconstrued in the absolute worst way.

 

[Ahtu]

It more along the line it comes across has her not understanding Harry because he doesn't want to fight Voldemort he has to fight. And sounds like she saying she likes him because he is hero. Which he doesn't want to be, Basically what said came across a lot differently than what she meant. And made her look horrible to the fandom. It doesn't help that in the next book she kissed Harry saying she doesn't want him to replace her if he comes across a veela Also sounded wrong to the fandom knowing Harry is going into the shit, basically she has the bad luck of everything she said being misconstrued in the absolute worst way.

Click to shrink...

So what you're saying is... Judgemental vindictiveness. Where they basically act like the old french secret police once said: "Give me 6 lines written by the most honorable man to ever lived, and I will give you a reason to hang him for it."

 

[S.I.N]

So what you're saying is... Judgemental vindictiveness. Where they basically act like the old french secret police once said: "Give me 6 lines written by the most honorable man to ever lived, and I will give you a reason to hang him for it."

Click to shrink...

More or less ginny statement was her saying she likes Harry for the good man he is and how he can't ignore what he needs to do. The problem was her saying he wouldn't be happy this word fucked her because it's wrong. People took that as her saying Harry wants to fight Voldemort that he is happy to be a hero when anyone who reads these books know Harry didn't want anything to do with Voldemort. Basically people took. Ginny's actions as her not getting how serious the situation is and treating Harry like a story book hero.

---

It doesn't help that she in the same book states she never gave up on being with him. Seeing as she had two boyfriend's this implies she is just playing with them,

---

this also bothered fans because if she didn't get over her crush does she actually know Harry for who he is. It basically a perfect storm to make ginny look like a shit person. I personally don't care for her but I don't hate her.

 

[Ahtu]

More or less ginny statement was her saying she likes Harry for the good man he is and how he can't ignore what he needs to do. The problem was her saying he wouldn't be happy this word fucked her because it's wrong. People took that as her saying Harry wants to fight Voldemort that he is happy to be a hero when anyone who reads these books know Harry didn't want anything to do with Voldemort. Basically people took. Ginny's actions as her not getting how serious the situation is and treating Harry like a story book hero.

---

It doesn't help that she in the same book states she never gave up on being with him. Seeing as she had two boyfriend's this implies she is just playing with them,

---

this also bothered fans because if she didn't get over her crush does she actually know Harry for who he is. It basically a perfect storm to make ginny look like a shit person. I personally don't care for her but I don't hate her.

Click to shrink...

Yeap, that 2nd part I can completely get behind. And that's some criticism I really do get. But she's also very young/a kid, she can get away with still having some such flaws. I wouldn't completely condemn her for that alone. Even if I think she deserves a slap and a long stern talking to for it. Which is also why I said I consider Hermione's advice somewhat disgusting.

And to summarize, I am much in the same boat as you. I don't really like her, but I don't hate her either.

Hmm? I actually think Harry idd does become "happy"(more like driven) to fight Voldemort. Which he realizes when Dumbledore basically asks him to think about it. He was very afraid of him when he was little. But as he gets older, realizes all the shit he has done, and is endlessly reminded of everything he stole from him - When he is asked to consider the implications of the prophecy, he finally realizes that he does have the drive to fight him. All the reasons, all the emotional baggage driving him, and their rather hardcore political dispute shall we say.

 

[S.I.N]

Yeap, that 2nd part I can completely get behind. And that's some criticism I really do get. But she's also very young/a kid, she can get away with still having some such flaws. I wouldn't completely condemn her for that alone. Even if I think she deserves a slap and a long stern talking to for it. Which is also why I said I consider Hermione's advice somewhat disgusting.

And to summarize, I am much in the same boat as you. I don't really like her, but I don't hate her either.

Hmm? I actually think Harry idd does become "happy"(more like driven) to fight Voldemort. Which he realizes when Dumbledore basically asks him to think about it. He was very afraid of him when he was little. But as he gets older, realizes all the shit he has done, and is endlessly reminded of everything he stole from him - When he is asked to consider the implications of the prophecy, he finally realizes that he does have the drive to fight him. All the reasons, all the emotional baggage driving him, and their rather hardcore political dispute shall we say.

Click to shrink...

Agreed, the hatred is a bit much but fans can get ridiculous. I can get rabid in my dislike of certain characters so I at least get it I've gone on many a rant about Naruto or issei from dxd.