RedX
Not too sore, are you?
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2014
- Messages
- 431
- Likes received
- 2,140
Hmmm, from what I recall Professor Snape advised her that this was a horrendously bad idea.
Nope. I just searched through the story again. His involvement seems to have consisted entirely of taking Hermione and Harry to the ministry, thinking "Snape readily acknowledged the necessity of seeing to the girl's safety via the servant registration Potter had arranged, even to the point of agreeing to go along to assist them with the whole ordeal. It was about time, in his opinion; he had come close to saying as much to the girl's father over a year previous".
Nothing about, yanno, physically sticking close to Harry being in any way important. So that's another adult saying "take this one precaution, then run along now"- and Hermione took that precaution, and it only helped because it was tangentially related to the problem so another group of folks had the chance to get massively lucky.
Yup, and I don't think anyone else advised her it was a good idea, they simply didn't grab her and tell her what a horrible idea it was, mostly because they didn't know what was going on.
Then (a) they're incompetent because the situation is readily obvious to any responsible adult involved, and (b) anyone who did know what was going on- Harry, Abigail, Snape, and Dumbledore- deserves even more blame for not getting anyone else involved, despite it being the matter of a ten-second conversation. (Heck, Harry did get Hermione's parents involved- just for the Servant thing. Did he ever even consider that they were in charge of her summer itinerary, too? Eh, Harry's a kid, give him a pass. We know Snape must have realized so, but we also know his solution was a purely reactive social and political one that didn't actually help prevent her from getting permawiped, so he's already got the idiot ball firmly welded on.)
Then there's the whole matter of the Emergency Portkey, yet another security feature arranged for this situation to allow Hermione to go about her life... which also did nothing. Less blame to be assigned here, unless there's such a thing as a contingent portkey that reacts to its wearing being stunned or the like, in which case she should have had one of those. Its very existence- another security feature that doesn't involve Harry being constantly by her side- was another situation in which several knowledgeable adults had a chance to say "This isn't going to be enough! Go with Harry!" to her... and didn't.
Still, again, I can accept that a titanic Rube Goldberg tragedy of errors lead to this situation. I must simply point out that none of the errors were Hermione's, and everyone should be reassuring her that it was in no way her fault and that everyone who did mess up will be doing their damnedest not to in the future.