Ack
(Verified Ratbag) (Unverified Great Old One)
- Joined
- Feb 12, 2014
- Messages
- 7,471
- Likes received
- 77,713
There are multiple threads (not going to reference them here) where it's been thoroughly explored just how unrealistic it is to have three girls turn an entire school against one unassuming non-remarkable teenager. Not just "I don't know her" but "If she's being bullied, we actively ignore it". Including the staff. Even before Sophia ended up as a Ward and landed on the 'protected species' list.Just because you work in a field where you deal with the bottom 5% of human terribleness doesn't mean the world is ALL SHIT ALL THE TIME.
Also how unrealistic it is that not one student took pictures or footage of Taylor going into the locker and then posted them to social media.
Also how unrealistic it is that the cops (and health department, and maybe FBI, as some people have suggested) didn't crack down on the entire school after the locker incident.
Also how unrealistic it is that Danny was unable to get more of a concession out of the school than paying the medical bills (and didn't pull Taylor out of school altogether).
(When my brother was in high school, he fractured his wrist doing something silly, so it got put in a cast. Some of the older boys thought it was funny to karate-chop the cast until it broke. He got moved to a different school.)
I mean, I can see the Doylist reasons for all that, but Watson is scratching for justifications.
It's like he took all his worst experiences and loaded them on to one character, ignoring the larger social network that may or may not have allowed it to happen.
Just saying.