al103
Not too sore, are you?
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2013
- Messages
- 352
- Likes received
- 3,552
Yeah, no. She applies "good office worker = promoted to more important office worker" to "good soldier = promoted to ... oh, wait "more important soldier" is on entirely different promotion track to "rearline officer"". That's like expecting to be a good plumber and get office job in result, no you will be just sent to clean more important toilets. Basic logic failure.Not to take away from your point that it's mostly not even Tanja's fault this time, I'd argue that Tanya never really comes to crazy conclusions. She applies paradigms that she's learnt without nuance or flexibility, and the result is that the otherwise logical modelling is completely off.
Yes, there are "if everybody was rational actor" mistakes, but basic analysis failures are just as often.