Scygnus
Well worn.
- Joined
- Jun 2, 2018
- Messages
- 6,615
- Likes received
- 48,428
I'm once again reminded:
You know that bit from Labyrinth? And half a dozen other stories?
The riddle where you wind up at a fork in the road, with two people. You can ask each one question, and one always tells the truth while the other always lies.
The technically correct answer is "If you were the other, which path would you say is the correct one?" and the liar points to the wrong path because the honest one would point to the correct path, while the honest one points to the same path because he knows the liar would lie and say the wrong path is the right one. So you go the other way.
Seems simple enough.
Well yes, but actually no. In any practical situation, encountering two riddlers at a fork in the path is weird and suspicious. If you're indeed questing, they were likely both sent by your villain.
So the actual answer is that they're BOTH lying. Also entirely possible that both paths are wrong and there's a third path, either oblique or counter-intuitive, especially when dealing with things like Fae (again, Labyrinth,) where the shortest distance between two points may not in fact be a line.
You know that bit from Labyrinth? And half a dozen other stories?
The riddle where you wind up at a fork in the road, with two people. You can ask each one question, and one always tells the truth while the other always lies.
The technically correct answer is "If you were the other, which path would you say is the correct one?" and the liar points to the wrong path because the honest one would point to the correct path, while the honest one points to the same path because he knows the liar would lie and say the wrong path is the right one. So you go the other way.
Seems simple enough.
Well yes, but actually no. In any practical situation, encountering two riddlers at a fork in the path is weird and suspicious. If you're indeed questing, they were likely both sent by your villain.
So the actual answer is that they're BOTH lying. Also entirely possible that both paths are wrong and there's a third path, either oblique or counter-intuitive, especially when dealing with things like Fae (again, Labyrinth,) where the shortest distance between two points may not in fact be a line.